Saturday 1 May 2010

No 9831, Saturday 01 May 10, Sankalak

ACROSS
1   - Dishonest behaviour, certainly not comedians' trade (5,8) - FUNNY BUSINESS
10 - Cold and aloof humour, hot attraction in the north (9) - {WITH}{DRAW}{N}(Correction - {WIT}{H}{DRAW}{N} )
11 - Piece of music from a player on downhill run (5) - RONDO [T]
12 - Behind time in a way, in the outskirts of Tilbury (5) - T{A}{RD}Y
13 - Name an action document, a legal one (5,4) - {TITLE} {DEED}
14 - Something for the smoker or a loose woman, say (6) - HOOKAH(~hooker)
16 - Moan about conservative Korea accepting accusation initially (5) - {C}{RO{A}K}
19 - What a job seeker must — be suitable (5) - APPLY [DD]
20 - Strange destiny of a small number of shares (3,3) - {ODD} {LOT}
25 - Very old and primitive dame alive to change (9) - MEDIAEVAL*
26 - The range of a train to New Dehi (express) skirting famous university (5) - G{AMU}T I remember travelling on the GT Express from Chennai to Delhi in the 50's, used to take almost 3 days I think. The first class cubicles had attached toilets!!
27 - It enables the police to make a charge (5) - LATHI [CD]
28 - Severely criticise one held in players entrance (9) - {CAST}{I}{GATE}
29 - Breaking into pieces an ornament, a gift trashed (13) - FRAGMENTATION*
DOWN
2   - Such a motive is not what it appears to be (8) - ULTERIOR [CD]
3   - A pet name for a donkey (5) - NODDY [E]
4   - Skin-deep may be, but it has its appeal (6) - BEAUTY [CD]
5   - Southern Railway admits girl is clean (8) - {S}{ANITA}{RY}
6   - Child-minder would sure mind a distraction (9) - NURSEMAID*
7   - Musician who could burn the capital of Romania (6) - SINGE{R}
8   - A change for a singular, wicked old woman (6) - {S}{WITCH}
9   - Drink for a man of religion, kept in a plaything (5) - TO{DD}Y Ever tried Toddy in the evening, Oooooh what a stink.
15 - Asking the umpire can be fascinating (9) - APPEALING [DD]
17 - Bone, large cervical variety with no trace of rot (8) - C{L}AVICLE(r)*
18 - Fruit container with nothing but graphite (8) - {PLUM}{BAG}{O}
21 - Sway with one who adds up (6) - TOTTER [DD]
22 - Got a whiff of freshwater fish (5) - SMELT [DD]

23 - Moneylender gets rid of councillor for journalist (6) - (cr)EDITOR
24 - Where may one misplace something in an American state? A cupboard (6) - C{LOSE}T
26 - Ground grain, to the mill it is something useful (5) - GRIST [DD]


19 comments:

  1. Hi
    It is no ULTERIOR FUNNY BUSINESS if an EDITOR MR NODDY who SMELT of TODDY made of GRIST on this breath TOTTER(ED) out of a SANITARY CLOSET made of PLUMBAGO, and CASTIGATE(s) a NURSEMAID, who is a RONDO SINGER and a BEAUTY APPLY(ing) lotions, for being WITHDRAWN and TARDY, attacks her with an entire GAMUT of CREAK(ing) LATHI or a SWITCH, causing FRAGMENTATION of her CLAVICLE, APPEALING to her to give him a TITLE DEED to the ODD LOT(s) of MEDIAEVAL HOOKAH
    NODDY and TODDY being rhyming pair. Rondo had to be Googled for confirmation.
    Singer reminds me of an anecdote about a gang of comedians (I am not sure if it was Groucho and gang) who received a request from a fan for a photo ‘ Singed’ all round and gleefully took a lighter and sent a singed photo; only to receive a letter saying “I had asked for a singed photo, you have sent a signed one”.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hello friends

    Took time to get GAMUT and PLUMBAGO. Otherwise, smooth sailing.

    A happy weekend to you all.

    ReplyDelete
  3. @COL
    10 - Cold and aloof humour, hot attraction in the north (9) - {WITH}{DRAW}{N}

    Shoud be {WIT}{H}{DRAW}{N}
    humour - WIT
    hot - H
    attraction - DRAW
    north - N
    Defn: Cold and aloof - WITHDRAWN

    ReplyDelete
  4. @ Col: Liked the illustration of both homophones for 14a

    ReplyDelete
  5. Thanks Venkatesh,
    I saw the error simultaneously but you beat me to the draw.

    ReplyDelete
  6. THC No 9825 Saturday 24 Apr 10

    10 A - Time ran out for one of Islam's high achievements (7) - MINARET

    Economic times, Mumbai, 30 Apr 10 (Page no 21)

    24 A - Time ran out for one of Islam's high achievements (7)

    What a coincidence!

    ReplyDelete
  7. The Economic Times crossword number is 4586

    ReplyDelete
  8. The same clue appeared in ET crossword (Mumbai) 3599 previously on 28-7-2007.

    ReplyDelete
  9. 3D Neddy

    http://www.thefreedictionary.com/neddy

    ReplyDelete
  10. Since we are in a series by Sankalak, it needs to be clarified that THC 9825 was by a different setter.

    ReplyDelete
  11. 10A...

    HOOKER and HOOKAH

    Homophones maybe in the UK but definitely not in India, seeing that Indian accents are predominantly rhotic.

    ReplyDelete
  12. 3 - A pet name for a donkey (5) - NODDY [E]

    It is NEDDY.

    ReplyDelete
  13. But Indian crossword setters could be more British/American than the British/American!

    ReplyDelete
  14. 26A - The range of a train to New Dehi (express) skirting famous university (5) - G{AMU}T

    One would need extra brains to think of two difficult leads, Grand Trunk and Aligarh Muslim University, together within the deadline !

    3D - A pet name for a donkey (5) - NODDY [E]

    As suggested by Giridhar and Sandhya, NEDDY is more appropriate. I too took it as NEDDY. Incidentally, a combination of both, a NODDING DONKEY is found near oilfields. :-)

    ReplyDelete
  15. CLUELESS of the forumhub also votes for NEDDY!

    ReplyDelete
  16. @Dan: Not quite sure if 'Hookah-Hooker' are not recognized as homophones. As a pre-teen, I remember reading a joke in the Illustrated Weekly of India. The joke went like this:

    Teacher visiting a student's home rings the bell. The door's answered by her student young jim.

    Teacher: Good afternoon, Jim. Are your parents in?
    Jim: Mum and Dad's out. Gone to the movies, I 'spect.
    Teacher: Really, Jim! Where's your grammar?
    Jim: Oh, she's upstairs takin' her nap.

    I distinctly remember not getting this joke. My grandfather (graduate of Univ of Madras, 1918) explained that li'l Jim thought the teacher was asking for his grandma.

    After that, I had come across PG Wodehouse rhyming 'cheetahs' and 'cheaters' in Ring for Jeeves, 'ringers' and 'stingah's', the last mentioned being a caricature of a Colonial accented pronunciation of the name of cocktail, very popular in the Gymkhana's of Hong Kong, Singapore and India.

    ReplyDelete
  17. LNS
    The point that Dan makes is that the homophones don't work when the words are uttered by most Indians. I agree!
    As for the joke that you quote, you must remember Indian publications often lifted/lift jokes from foreign publications which will have such gags on the basis of how words are pronounced in those countries.
    The above joke can be appreciated only on a cerebral level - not naturally!

    ReplyDelete
  18. A Scot gave a testimonial to his manservant when he left his service. "R__ worked to his entire satisfaction. If you're thinking of giving him a berth, make it a wide one."
    How many of us can laugh outright at this joke?
    I was some 12 years old when this one appeared in RD; my father read it to me and explained what it was all about.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Chaturvasi, I guess the Scots joke is more along the lines of a dry British joke. To appreciate it you need to know some idiomatic English obviously.

    My original take to Dan was that it realized in India even way back that the way the English pronounced a terminal "-a-" in Indian words rhymed very much with the "-er" type words.

    You can see the same thing in Satyajit Ray's 'Shatranj ke Khiladi' . Gen Outram, played by Sir Laurence Olivier, ranting about Indian morals. He says, "nautch girls, mootter wives, where does it all end" or something like that. I wondered when I first saw the movie what this 'mootter wife' was. Many years later a Muslim colleague told me that he was refering to the the custom of "mutaa marriage" which has a validity like a contract. The end date is usually specified. So like you engage in a marriage for a fixed period of time. Like a contract, this marriage is dissolved if not renewed!

    See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nikah_mut‘ah

    ReplyDelete

deepakgita@gmail.com