Tuesday 18 January 2011

No 10054, Tuesday 18 Jan 11, Sankalak

ACROSS
1   - A very long time for a sad one going round the earth (4,4) - {BLUE} {MOON}
5   - Business mogul's domain (6) - EMPIRE [CD]
10 - Governor wearing rigid piece of bed linen (5) - {S{HE}ET}
11 - Such a victory from an avalanche? (9) - LANDSLIDE [CD]
12 - Complimentary weapon for one on his own (9) - {FREE}{LANCE}
13 - Tax on business causes tears to flow (5) - RATES*
14 - Vigorous, like some powerful US tycoons (5) - LUSTY [T]
16 - Tower for defence built by Babar in Chithor initially (8) - BARBI(C)AN*
18 - Songbird — also a celebrity swimmer (8) - {STAR}{LING}
20 - Red dye used in noise control (5) - EOSIN*
24 - Freight that makes a vehicle move (5) - {CAR}{GO}
25 - Plain, starved of affection, consumed a drop of nicomorphine (9) - {UNADOR{N}ED}
27 - One-time tax I have found to be too much (9) - {EX}{CESS}{I'VE}
28 - Holy one, depressed human abandoning man (5) - {SAD}{HUman}
29 - Provincial governor, with appeal, reversed role (6) - {SA}{TRAP<-}
30 - Look for gold from a potential team member (8) - PROSPECT [DD]
DOWN
1   - Timid and self-conscious at a boisterous party, develops flu (7) - {BASH}{FUL*}
2   - Do not consume so much if it serves no purpose (7) - {USE}{LESS}
3   - Element, Tritium, found in food (5) - {ME{T}AL}
4   - Where to be for a Net-conference (2,4) - ON LINE [CD]
6   - Scrooge, fit but very unhappy (9) - {MISER}{ABLE} My No 1 clue for the day
7   - Like Dostoyevsky's Myshkin (7) - IDIOTIC [CD]
8   - Philosopher who had sore men treated (7) - EMERSON*
9   - Cover for a bender at church (7) - KNEEPAD [CD]
15 - Part of the Pacific that allows the old English to transform (6,3) - {YE}{LLOW S(E)A*}
17 - Hormone essential for glucose metabolism (7) - INSULIN [E]
18 - The competitor's objective upsets coppers on duty (7) - {SUC<-}{CESS} Not a very good definition in my view.
19 - Fruit, a tropic variety (7) - APRICOT*
21 - How a legislature usually gets adjourned (4,3) - SINE DIE [CD]
22 - Admittedly, there is an absence of uncertainty (2,5) -  {NO} {DOUBT}
23 - Move headlong in one's chosen occupation (6) - CAREER [DD]
26 - A refuge where one may find dates? (5) - OASIS [CD]


30 comments:

  1. 18 - The competitor's objective upsets coppers on duty (7) - {SUC<-}{CESS} Not a very good definition in my view.
    ---

    I don't think 'coppers' for CUS works.

    ReplyDelete
  2. No doubt I like 22D.

    Question to solvers at large, how important is the surface reading and meaning of a clue to you personally?

    The reason I ask this is, in today's puzzle there were clues which were perfectly described and defined that makes solving them unambiguous and easy. But on the surface they made no sense.

    ReplyDelete
  3. A very long time for a sad one going round the earth (4,4)
    ---
    Gita raised a query in the Orkut community but I did not respond there.

    The clue would work well w/o 'a', though there might be some loss in the surface reading.
    If we remove the 'a',
    sad, adj., will give BLUE.
    one going round the earth - MOON.
    With 'a' in the text, 'sad' becomes a noun and that does not yield BLUE.

    ReplyDelete
  4. It is important to me. If a clue has a good surface and is also clued well, I get double the pleasure in solving it. It is of course more difficult for the setter, but affords him the ability to 'mislead' the solver.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Surface reading and meaning of the clue are definitely important, otherwide it would be just gibberish aka NJ style.

    ReplyDelete
  6. My 8:45 was in response to Bhavan 8:38

    ReplyDelete
  7. I haven't solved this puz but after I read Bhavan's post I scrolled up and the following clue hit my eye:
    Red dye used in noise control (5) EOSIN*
    The surface reading leaves much to be desired.
    Years ago there was an anonymous composer in whose work most of the clues were like this: put A and B together (or A in B or whatever) and get C with the overall clue making little sense.

    ReplyDelete
  8. We will get plenty of nonsensical stuff from tomorrow for the next 6 days, excluding Sunday of course.

    ReplyDelete
  9. @CV, you have summed up the feeling perfectly.

    The A, B, C parts were fine (mostly), but the overall effect of each clue didn't paint any good picture on the surface.

    ReplyDelete
  10. @Colonel : Week of drudgery begins tomorrow ? Was blissfully unaware.

    Whoever is in charge of xwords at The Hindu can think of randomising the setters to keep solvers on the edge.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Thought this was another ok crossword - but must admit to getting kneecap rather than kneepad for 9D. Bracing myself for a week of NJ, she really is the one setter I cannot get to grips with.

    ReplyDelete
  12. 10a - I am not getting - Is it Governor = he? Can anybody explain?

    ReplyDelete
  13. Hi
    Had to cheat on BARBICAN. Favourite clue BLUE MOON.
    12a FREELANCE reminded of the absentee Sir Richard Lancelot. Right ? Or Left ? Or Right and Left ? Or write and left ? Or R L, the Daiji World man ?

    Surface reading should be meaningful that is what gives flavor to otherwise insipid string of letters.

    Governor= His Excellency=HE

    ReplyDelete
  14. Good morning
    my clue of the day is 15 d. though i got it how "Ye" fit in i cant decipher...similarly i am not too sure about 2e d also.
    mathu

    ReplyDelete
  15. Mathu,

    Ye is 'the' in Old English.

    Do not consume so much = USE LESS
    if it serves no purpose = USELESS

    ReplyDelete
  16. Wasn't as clean as his previous offerings. But I'll still take this any day compared to what's probably in store for the next week! :)

    My CoD : SADHU . :):):)

    ReplyDelete
  17. A decent offering, in my opinion.

    Debate can go on unabated on the demerits of certain cluing but at the end of solving Sankalak's puzzle one does derive a satisfaction
    in this pastime rather than hair-splitting experience (due to start).

    ReplyDelete
  18. Another aside from my treasure chest to keep the ball rolling:

    How is Manmohan Singh connected to Miss India ?

    ReplyDelete
  19. Both are down to the fig leaf.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Metaphorically, yes, CV. But to make things simpler (if at all), may I mention that the MS is not our PM and MI is not a lady !

    And neither Bob nor Google is our uncle (at least in this sort of thing)

    ReplyDelete
  21. Bhavan, I second others' sentiments regarding surface reading. An ideal clue, for me, should be a "proper," maybe even a witty statement in and of itself. It should not be misleading, of course. And if it relates to the solution in some way, though not necessarily in an &lit way, then that would be perfect!

    Spiffytrix has the knack for doing this, IMO, and I'd rather see his(?) grids featured often, in place of the algorithms that we sometimes are made to follow.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Both are down to the fig leaf.

    Do you mean 'One has nothing to share and the other has nothing to wear.'

    ReplyDelete
  23. this Manmohan (not PM) 'miss'ed India? I am somewhere there but not there!

    ReplyDelete
  24. Regarding 1213:

    It is connected to 1930.

    ReplyDelete
  25. Paddy almost said it. Manmohan was also somewhere but not there ! He missed India, as Paddy has deduced, but Manmohan's Miss India is a noun and he was inside it, though the 'miss' was used by some others to refer to it as a verb.

    ReplyDelete
  26. Saw a nice clue in today's DNA newspaper Cryptic CW, liked the surface reading :-)

    Women have many odd ideas (6)

    ReplyDelete
  27. L-ADIES*

    &lit too :-)

    ReplyDelete
  28. The clue that Col Deepak cites from DNA is from the cryptic crossword in the main section.
    The crossword itself is the same as that carried in the NIE, except that the syndicate supplies different series to different papers.
    The crossword in the afterhours is set by you-know-who.
    BTW, the serial number of the xwd in the main section differs from edn to edn, I think.

    ReplyDelete
  29. Both are down to the fig leaf.

    Do you mean 'One has nothing to share and the other has nothing to wear.'

    I was reminded of: What's the difference between a vest and a langota?

    One is wear and tear and the other one is tear and wear.

    ReplyDelete

deepakgita@gmail.com