Satyen Nabar's Sun Spl analysed

Tuesday, 31 October 2023

No 14008, Tuesday 31 Oct 2023, Vidwan

Solution to 29A has been deliberately left unsolved and is to be answered only by a non-regular / novice commenter, with proper annotation. Those who have answered earlier in the week, please give others a chance.

Open for anyone to answer, if not solved by 1 PM.

ACROSS
1   Champion's back! (7) SUPPORT [DD]
5   One's buried in mobile, never shifting (7) VEERING {VEER{1}N}*G 'G' from?
9   Sappers boy consumed by disease, initially got sympathetic response (9) RESONATED {RE}{SON}{ATE}{Di...e}
10 Oddly look in for ground (5) FLOOR {F{LoOk}OR}
11 Simplicity of native English bum (7) NAIVETE {NATIVE+E}*
12 Connect Aryans had with a sweet liquid source (7) NECTARY [T]
14 Oh! Love fresh, cold/hot, cheap brew (5) HOOCH {OH+O}*{C}{H}
16 Report by government guys! On time! (9) STATEMENT {STATE}{MEN}{T}
19 Barbies, consuming sorbet endlessly for ringers! (9) DOORBELLS {DO{sORBEt}LLS}
22 Letter at the back, backwards! (5) THETA {AT<=}<=>{THE} (Correction - {AT}{THE<=}<= See comments)
23 Recall manoeuvres Cinderella deployed! (7) RESCIND [T]
24 Wine stains in similar manner (7) MARSALA {MARS}{A LA}
26 Cold Play, I, Old Lady and Old Man, for example (5) CACTI {C}{ACT I}
28 Sending out, consuming, stifling boyfriend (9) EMANATING {E{MAN}ATING}
29 Lords over the French striptease dancers (7) P?E?E?S (Addendum - PEELERS {PEE{LE}RS} - See comments)
30 Discussion remains misguided (7) SEMINAR*

DOWN
1   Crushed noisily, crushed violently around, once in the middle (9) SCRUNCHED {SCRU{oNCe}HED*}
2   One eating sea food spreads one scoop virus!! (11) PISCIVOROUS {1+SCOOP+VIRUS}*
3   Trace naked staff at a night club (5) OUNCE bOUNCEr
4   Scraps start-up consuming time and energy (7) TATTERS {START}* over {T}{E}
5   Loved antagonistic part of Upanishads (7) VEDANTA [T]
6   Fine! Face it without a working professional (9) EFFICIENT {FINE+FaCE+IT}*
7   She saved Odysseus at home with love (3) INO {IN}{O}
8   King abducted by murderous left-wing writer (5) GORKY {GOR{K}Y}
13 Elementary - a nice bread and a shot! (11) ABECEDARIAN {A}{NICE+BREAD+A}*
15 Yes! His bride managed to blend (9) HYBRIDISE {Y+HIS+BRIDE}*
17 Mostly cultivate an oil seed (3) TIL TILl
18 A square, flat and a right kind of fish (9) TRAFALGAR {FLAT+A+R}*{GAR}
20 Left persons who avoid duty in absence of leader for those who are there to stay! (7) LODGERS {L}{dODGERS}
21 Almost identical vessels or boats in China (7) SAMPANS {SAMe}{PANS}
23 Fast bowler returns for rundown (5) RECAP<=
25 True male territory (5) REALM {REAL}{M}
27 He resides in each extremist's heart! (3) CHE Semi&lit

Reference List
Sappers = RE(Royal Engineers), English = E, Cold = C, Hot = H, The in French = LE, Time = T, Energy = E, King = K, Yes = Y, Right = RLeft = L, Male = M

34 comments:

  1. 29 Across solved, very nice clue
    Let others try

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. TBH I find it rather bland. Would fit just fine in Lovatts 🥱

      Delete
  2. To be taken as endlessly on either side...

    ReplyDelete
  3. In this case both ends are being removed, the front end and the back end.

    ReplyDelete
  4. 5A VEERING... I also don't understand the G.

    MARSALA and SCRUNCHED were both charmingly clued. ABCEDARIAN and GORKY were a bit too obscure and archaic even for me. Not going to spice up any conversations in my future.

    Weird typos in the online version, 25D REAIM and 27D "CUE". :/

    Some hits, some misses... and yet somehow time marches on

    ReplyDelete
  5. 'Endslessly', if I may say so. Much discussed.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Replies
    1. Yeah I guess so. This one also felt flimsy to me.

      Delete
    2. Msy be some justification. This is a down clue. Up is a typical reversal indicator.

      Delete
    3. Thank you Sree Sree, this explanation helped me get some sleep

      Delete
  7. THC 14007 (Yesterday, Oct 30) by Karaoke has a clue in which BRACE is "wearing" {O}{AT}.
    20 Couple wearing nothing at regatta (4,4) BOAT RACE {B{O}{AT}RACE}
    Here, A "wearing" B means that B goes inside A.
    ---
    THC 13999 (Thursday Oct 19) by Dr. X has a clue in which {IN} is "wearing" THAT.
    2D Soldier's helmet is so cool to wear (3,3) TINHAT
    Here, B "to wear" A means that B goes inside A. (The opposite of the prior example)
    ---
    From Clue Clinic by Azed (http://www.clueclinic.com/index.php/container-contents-indicators/):
    "wearing" and "wears" are insertion indicators, meaning that A "wearing" B or A "wears" B means that A goes inside B.
    ---
    Which setter got it right? In my opinion, Dr. X and Azed are in complete agreement, while Karaoke's clue has the inverse interpretation.
    ---
    Both puzzles were excellent regardless.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. IMO, "wearing" is an insertion indicator. A wearing B -> A inside B

      Delete
    2. I'd say it absolutely reads more naturally as an insertion indicator. Things that are "worn" like clothes, go on the outside.

      However, there's a British slang use for "wearing" https://www.thefreedictionary.com/wear (#11) that means "Accepting", which I think one could argue could apply inversely.

      I'd accept either, but the second, (wearing = "Accepting") is more tricky, backwards, and very much the exception.

      Delete
    3. Depends on how you read it.
      "A" Wearing "b" Or
      "A wearing", B.
      First is verb, second one is more like adjective.
      Like saying
      Guy in blue jacket or
      Blue jacket guy.

      Delete
    4. Thanks all for your views. I am of the view, 'wearing' means bearing, having, displaying, featuring [as per Chambers thesaurus] and hence can work otherwise too.

      On the lighter side, take it as innerwear!

      I have also seen the following clue:
      Hat-wearing model? That's right (5) TI[T]LE

      Delete
  8. Liked MARSALA, SEMINAR, TATTERS.
    Had put 1A as SPONSOR and then corrected it.
    One doubt: What is the anagram indicator in 18D?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. "Kind of"
      https://cryptics.fandom.com/wiki/List_of_anagram_indicators

      Delete
  9. Yes, shot can mean try, but shot also can mean "broken down" ie "My car's alternator is shot and needs to be replaced"

    See the adjective def #2 here: https://www.thefreedictionary.com/shot

    ReplyDelete
  10. So yes, shot is an anagrind, and when used as such, I think of the above adjectival definition.

    ReplyDelete
  11. There he lay on the FLOOR...
    Smell of HOOCH EMANATING.
    Maxim GORKY's book in TATTERS...

    AII because of the RECAP. ( His pal who had just returned from the camp mentioning that all DOOR BELLS were unanswered and there were no inmates in the camp.)

    Vladimir had to RESCIND - cancel his booking without any refund.
    What happened next?
    A fracas in TRAFALGAR Square.


    ReplyDelete
  12. Many anagrams helped solving even rare ones like 13D. 5D Vedanta nice hidden letter clue. Liked 9A, 4D, 20D, 23D too...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Couldn't figure out 5A and 8D. Saw the solutions here

      Delete
  13. 22D – (PEE(LE)RS)
    Lords – PEERS - A Nobleman , a member of the British peerage
    The French – LE
    Def. Dancers – Peelers

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Well solved Prasannarao. I am sure you were waiting for "the clock struck one"

      Delete
    2. Yes indeed!! Well done.
      The clock struck one, the mouse ran down!!

      Delete
    3. yes. abs.right. I was waiting for the same. Thanks a lot sir. (Paddy & KKR)

      Delete
  14. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  15. 29a PEELERS = Striptease dancers
    PEERS = Lords
    LE = the French
    PEE+LE+RS
    Over containment indicator

    ReplyDelete
  16. Completed Vidwan fully after a lo...ng time.
    VEERING just fell into place thanx to GORKY.
    My fav - DOORBELLS, MARSALA, TRAFALGAR.
    Thanx Vidwan!

    ReplyDelete

deepakgita@gmail.com