Monday 8 November 2021

No 13396, Monday 08 Nov 2021, Vidwan

Solution to 14A has been deliberately left unsolved and is to be answered only by a non-regular / novice commenter, with proper annotation. Those who have answered earlier in the week, please give others a chance.

ACROSS
9   Cram the ground for game being played again (7) REMATCH*
10 Check from a source (7) EXAMINE {EX}{A}{MINE}
11 Joint bank lending division (5) ANKLE [T]
12 Maoists are detached, read minds (3,6) RED GUARDS {REaD}{GUARDS}
13 Something consumed casually (4) IDLY [DD]
14 Blame the French source like Spooner (6) M?L?G? (Addendum - MALIGN (~ la mine to malign) - See comments)  
18 On the contrary, sitting First Lady is a survivor (4,3,8) LAST MAN STANDING (Opposite of sitting first lady)
20 Reverses briefs, one goes out wearing nothing! (6) UNDOES UND(-1+o)OES
22 He fights back in courtroom usually (4) SUMO [T<=]
26 Yes, leaving old Mumbai. Its lost, essentialy varicosed, too loud (9) BOMBASTIC {BOMBAy}{ITS*}{v..iCo..d}
27 Mostly family constitutes a criminal organisation (5) MAFIA {FAMIly}*{A} Mostly means how many letters  2.3, 4 ... 
28 Occasionally seen as laid-back on the coast creature (3,4) SEA LION {SeEn+As+LaId}{ON}
29 Highland philosopher, as some may call him (7) PLATEAU (~plato)

DOWN
1   Drama about sick, old beast (9) ARMADILLO {DRAMA*}{ILL}{O}
2   Recommendation for an addict — a special kind of cigarette (9) SMOKELESS {SMOKE LESS}
3   Is it the base metal ultimately? (5) STEEL Tail Acrostic Semi&lit
4   Abel’s position at the Lord’s (5,3) THIRD MAN [DD]
5   What one calls a system where only a handful reportedly ploughed land, knight being absent (6) FEUDAL (~few){FEU}{LAnD}* Semi&lit
6   It breathes in air in traditional air-conditioner, absorbing oxygen and ultimately facilitating movement (5,4) FALUN GONG {FA{LUNG}G{O}N{f...nG} Anno pending (Addendum - {FA{LUNG}{O}N}{f...nG} - See comments)
7   This bold sort makes billboard sign (5) LIBRA {LIBRA+BOLD}*=BILLBOARD} [CA]
8   Flirt starts to talk enticingly after spouse exits (5) TEASE Acrostic
15 A small, not rare kind of rock, a building block (5,4) AMINO ACID {A}{MINOr}{ACID}
16 Being in flux, one question UEFA mostly lied about (9) LIQUEFIED {L{1}{Q}{UEFa}IED}
17 Donkey roaming around America (9) IGNORAMUS {ROAMING}*{US}
19 Sip beverage (South-Indian style), reportedly for proof (4,4) TEST COPY (~taste kapi)
21 Musically, it could be perfect name for very powerful stuff that moves the world (6) OCTANE OCTA(+n-v)NE
23 A black-American English insult (5) ABUSE {A}{B}{US}{E}
24 City stiffled by Tottenham manager (5) AMMAN [T]
25 Coat brand’s about solemnity at heart (5) SMEAR {S{soleMnity}EAR}

Reference List
Are = A, The in French = LA, Yes = Y, Old = O, Knight = N, Rare = R, Kind of rock = ACID(rock), Question = Q, Name = N, Very = V, Black = B, English = E


TalePiece
By Dr RKE

In a lane near Meenakshi AMMAN temple, Madurai, is a tiny non-descript shop without any BILLBOARD SIGN. You will recognise it by the pot-bellied man (much like a SUMO wrestler) in a white dhoti and a sleeveless banian with his forehead SMEARed in holy ash and vermillion kumkum. Not to mention the BOMBASTIC songs coming from the old-fashioned cassette player. This is the destination for all IDLY lovers. It is popularly known as the Shanmugam Pillai malligai (jasmine) idly for its pure white colour and fluffiness. There is a bench but most customers have to stand on their ANKLEs on the pavement to taste this fabled idly. I have always wondered what high- OCTANE fuel he uses to keep the tiny shop SMOKELESS, in spite of the two stoves that work non-stop. This idly served with a LIQUEFIED thin sambar, kaara chutney and podi on the side, dished out on a stainless STEEL plate with a banana leaf cut to a round shape is sure to TEASE your tase buds. I guess someone must EXAMINE and find out what special AMINO ACID is there in the ulundu (urad dal) that he gets from his native village, that would make this idly to be the LAST MAN STANDING, if there were to be a competition for the best idly in the Deccan PLATEAU.

Apart from Pillai and his teenage son, there is no THIRD MAN who works there, for there is simply no space in that little shop. Madurai street food is much ABUSEd and MALIGNed, for its lack of cleanliness but you don’t need to be a VIDWAN- any IGNORAMUS knows that when eaten piping hot, the bacteria have no chance. I heard that he has raised his price recently. No, it is not because of the rising cost of production- he has to pay the MAFIA run by the local councillor protection money every month. If you want to do something for sustaining this culinary delight of Madurai, please pin it on Google Maps, tweet about it and post it on Facebook and Insta. I have done my bit by writing this talepiece.


38 comments:

  1. Breathes air in:lung
    Traditional ac: Fan
    Oxygen:O
    Ultimately f....G

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Okay, I put in an extra G, that's why I vould not annotate it

      Delete
    2. ShankarSen, agree. the art of surface seems to be not in consideration. (Cryptic is so much more than Literary charade!!!).

      As said earlier, I don't solve this setter. It's only as an alum of thcc blog that I even try.

      Delete
    3. Totally agree. The surface is very laboured. I deliberately kept this experimental clue and reaction is correct and expected.

      Delete
  2. 28a The word 'back' is not only superfluous but I think it is incorrect.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. +2
      I don't think it is needed for surface readi g also.

      Delete
    2. I think back here can be taken as support/join with

      Delete
    3. Won't work IMO, KKR ji. A backs B (across) and A supports B (down) = BA not AB

      Delete
    4. Backs is used a a juxtaposition indicator. However what AVM says has merit.

      Delete
  3. Replies
    1. As long as it is not classified as noble or precious

      Delete
    2. US CUSTOMS & BORDER PROTECTION
      WHAT IS A BASE METAL?
      Section XV, Note 3. defines “base metals” under the HTS. It reads:
      Throughout the schedule, the expression “base metals” means: iron and
      steel, copper, nickel, aluminum, lead, zinc, tin, tungsten (wolfram),
      molybdenum, tantalum, magnesium, cobalt, bismuth, cadmium, titanium,
      zirconium, antimony, manganese, beryllium, chromium, germanium,
      vanadium, gallium, hafnium, indium, niobium (columbium).

      Yes steel is an alloy but there is common usage where steel is a base metal.

      Delete
  4. 14a- MALIGN = blame : Spoonerism of La Mine. La=The in French and Mine =>source

    ReplyDelete
  5. 7d normally, CA is (def+x)=y or y+z.

    This and sign???


    It could have read
    This sign bold makes billboard

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. In CA This(clued word) + Fodder = New Word/phrase is standard. Your version is also correct.

      Delete
  6. 10a-- where does the EX come from?

    ReplyDelete
  7. Replies
    1. I think the hp is only to kapi. SIP as in sample/test. Taste is also a sample test.

      Delete
    2. COPY in any case doesnt sound like KAPI

      Delete
    3. copy
      /ˈkɒpi/

      From Google dict.

      Delete
    4. Homophones are dicey business! Specially when the pronunciations vary every few hundred kilometers in India. SIP = TASTE, SIP = SAMPLE , SAMPLE = TEST but SIP directly doesn't lead to TEST in my opinion.

      Delete
  8. Yes,it is iron. Coloquially they are used interchangeably though not correct.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Steel is defined asmetal in major dictionaries. Metal in generic usage covers alloys too. The "?" at the end wasa for indicating this aspect of the definition. Thanks

      Delete
    2. Metal no problem. Base metal was my Q

      Delete
    3. Chambers describes it as alloy. And as an ex-SAIl, it's def an alloy.

      Delete
    4. It is not a precious metal.

      Pl see Collins.

      Delete
  9. Question answered with question mark!!

    ReplyDelete
  10. Thanks for the feedback. Only 2 clues would qualify as being 'twisted'. FALUN GONG and TEST COPY.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Quite a tricky grid today, it was and waited till noon to ascertain where I had erred. For instance while attempting 10-A, as a journo, I presumed it to be CLARIFY or CONFIRM since 7-D was aptly solved by me as LIBRA.
    Well, 18-A happened to be a fantastic clue and so too 19-D.
    To a great extent, I do agree with what Mr. Sathia has opined in the sense, both Skullplougher and Vidwan have infused a novel trend vis-a-vis the conventional modes of clues.
    Thanks....

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Skullplougher!!! It's actually wrdplougher but this Freudian slip seems more accurate. :-)

      Delete
  12. Objective criticism is absolutely necessary.

    This is my 9th grid. I haven't received such comments. Some were totally justified. The experimental clue for FALUN GONG, I had put to see the reaction.

    The observation on TEST COPY is partly fair. Homophone clues have to take into account local accents. Like English refer to Scottish or Cockney accent.

    The observation on back as juxtaposition indicator is also correct.

    I focus on getting good surfaces but without any wordplay errors. There were just one slip up on WP i.e. the back as juxticator.

    Overall quality of surfaces could have been better, I agree.

    Will definitely keep that in mind and will improve in next grid sets!

    However I do suggest that there should be objective healthy exchanges with open mind.

    Thanks

    ReplyDelete

deepakgita@gmail.com