Monday, 15 November 2021

No 13402, Monday 15 Nov 2021, Vulcan

Solution to 23A has been deliberately left unsolved and is to be answered only by a non-regular / novice commenter, with proper annotation. Those who have answered earlier in the week, please give others a chance.

ACROSS
1   Preserve animal food (6) CANAPE {CAN}{APE}
4   Rate of a local tax, say (6) ASSESS {AS}{SESS(~cess)}
8   Selecting a picture (7) DRAWING [DD]
9   A time Spanish man hosted a politician (7) SENATOR {A}{T} in {SENOR}
11 Some new roles some ending in disaster (4,2,4) MORE OR LESS {ROLES+SOME+d...eR}*
12 Working with unknown variables in black (4) ONYX {ON}{Y}{X}
13 Setter is smiling in support (1-4) I-BEAM {I}{BEAM}
14 Hold on with difficulty (8) RESTRAIN {RE}{STRAIN}
16 Moves forward with issues ahead of time (8) ADVANCES [DD]
18 Fibre Marie developed (5) RAMIE*
20 Instant photo (4) SNAP [DD]
21 Convict hunted down outside town, caught (10) CONTRACTED {CON}{TRAC{T}ED}
23 Reluctant girl on medicine (7) ?S?A?E? (Addendum - ASHAMED - {ASHA}{MED} - See comments)
24 Model, praised, had great ambitions (7) ASPIRED*
25 Hostile Southeastern state basically (6) AVERSE {SE}<=>{AVER}
26 Notice split coming (6) ADVENT {AD}{VENT}

DOWN
1   Vehicle to leave with shipment (5) CARGO {CAR}{GO}
2   Location unknown at this time and at this place (7) NOWHERE {NOW}{HERE}
3   Roam about in fear — it’s all around (9) PANORAMIC {PAN{ROAM*}IC}
5   Details — these are before your eyes (5) SPECS [DD]
6   Charm of posh English manor — fantastic surroundings (7) ENAMOUR {U} in {E+MANOR}*
7   State leader’s conservative approach and narrative (9) STORYLINE {St..e}{TORY}{LINE}
10 Indicate regarding offer (9) REPRESENT {RE}{PRESENT}
13 Ones in country’s islands (9) INDONESIA {IND{ONES}IA}
15 Users, ripped-off after gym shutting down, at a loss (9) SURPRISED {USERS+RIPpeD}*
17 Calm primate eating vegetables (7) APPEASE {AP{PEAS}E}
19 State-Church separated as a system (7) MACHINE {MA{CH}INE}
21 Game contributed by the Dutch essentially (5) CHESS [T]
22 Fair and equal trial to begin with (5) EVENT {EVEN}{Tr..l}

Reference List
Time = T, Man in Spanish = SENOR, Unknown variables = X,Y, One = RE, Town = T, Notice = AD, Posh = U, English = E, Regarding = RE, Gym = PE, Church = CH 


39 comments:

  1. 23D Reluctant {ASHAMED} girl {ASHA} on medicine {MED}

    ReplyDelete
  2. Nice one from Vulcan. Surprised- hardly any comments.
    Surprise also everyday,until you see who the setter is. I think cotinupus run of one setter is a thing of tbe past.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Still handicapped. Getting the print edition late. Thi gs haven't settled down after the rains.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Nice crossword. Thank you Vulcan ji

    ReplyDelete
  5. Nice start to the week. My COD at this time and at this place was 'nowhere' to be seen!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Enjoyed the clues totally! 25A AVERSE too tricky!

      Delete
    2. MB,
      Do ypu know this auio-
      A man who was z co firmed atheist wanted to say loudly that God was nowhere. So he called a painter and asked him to writebit boldly in paint. Thebilliterate painter wrote
      God is now here.

      Delete
    3. +2 Good one, Paddy! ๐Ÿ‘๐Ÿ™‚

      Delete
  6. Thank you Mr. VJ (Vulcan) for letting me learn a new word CANAPE (1-A) and this has prompted my mood to be in tune with 13-A, I BEAM literally!
    In a nutshell, kudos to you for compiling this interesting grid though I failed in attempting 3, 6 and 22 in the DOWN slot and 18, 21 & 23 in the ACROSS clues.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Some observations. Pl take these objectively.

    1. Nice breezy grid with some wonderful clues particularly the ones for MOREORLESS, APPEASE and MACHINE

    2. Some issues need to be clarified

    12A. ONYX: The word 'in' is a standard insertion indicator and hence cannot be used as link word (that links WP and definition parts).  Moreover how BLACK = ONYX?

    13A. I-BEAM : Setter smiling = I beaming not I beam.

    1D. CARGO. The word 'with' is a standard juxticator (to connect parts of WP) and hence cannot act as link word (that connects WP to DEF part of the clue)

    15D. SURPRISED. GYM = EXERCISE as verb is ok but GYM = PE is not right as PE is a noun. Obviously GYM as noun is not PE either.

    22D. EVENT: FAIR is both fodder and definition which violates a basic rule. Only in & lit or semi & lit clues such overlap is allowed and this clue certainly isn't an & lit.

    Regards

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. 13a
      beam verb
      smile radiantly.
      "she beamed with pleasure"
      Similar:
      grin
      smile
      dimple
      grin like a Cheshire Cat
      twinkle
      smirk
      laugh
      be all smiles
      grinning
      smiling

      From dictionary

      Delete
    2. Definition of gym
      1: GYMNASIUM
      2: PHYSICAL EDUCATION

      From
      https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/gym

      Delete
    3. 12a I agree. With and in totally foxed me. I took def as working and kept searching for two letter word for black.

      Delete
    4. I disagree that just because "in" is an insertion indicator it cannot server as a connector. I think "wordplay in def" is an OK construction. I do think it can be questioned in terms of whether the cryptic reading is sound (I think it is OK, but not great), but just because some word/phrase is a wordplay indicator is not reason enough for it to not be OK as a connector (consider "of" for example), imo.

      Delete
    5. Agree with Viresh.
      Re beam= smiling. The crucial test is substitution in a sentence. Prasad, can you think of a sentence where 'beam' and 'smiling' can be used interchangeably? If yes, then it's fine.

      Delete
    6. I can't. I have been asking the same doubts.

      CV sir once said (may be not in exact words) " be the OED as it may the setter should be aware of its usage." I subscribe to that. Synonyms also have a context in which they are interchangeable.

      But I have been getting, "it's there in the dictionary" a lot these days. So I just stopped asking if it's there in the dictionary.

      Delete
    7. Even if beam = smiling (n), don't think clue works here with "is"

      Agree with Viresh ji on connector Vs wordplay indicator

      Have seen gym = PE in several puzzles

      Fair = Even (fรฆger) and Fair = Event (faire) have different roots. So it's ok IMO

      Delete
  8. Nice grid. My fav
    1. NOWHERE, PANORAMIC, MACHINE.
    2. Just a doubt - Is STORYLINE a single word? Shouldnt enu be 5,4?

    ReplyDelete
  9. Just a small reply to earlier comment -
    12a - working with unknown variables is ON + Y + X
    In black is the defn - onyx is mainly in black & rarely in green etc.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. https://www.ppgpaints.com/color/color-families/neutrals/onyx-black

      Delete
  10. 1d - again leave with is GO. Shipment is the defn. CARGO.
    My understanding

    ReplyDelete
  11. A brief Romance
    Although Ms.X was enamoured of the young senator, she was really surprised to meet him at an event in the panoramic surroundings of Indonesia.

    There, out of nowhere, he made a drawing, representing, more or less, his feelings for her. And then went down on one knee & proposed with a black onyx machine cut ring.

    With her mouth full of canapes & her eyes gleaming behind her specs, she felt so embarrassed, if not entirely ashamed.

    She was averse to such public advances. She had aspired for romance, but didn't expect to contract matrimony so soon.

    Assessing the situation, she restrained herself from laughing out loud. Supporting herself on the I Beam near by, she appeased him by accepting his ring for the time being.

    Eventually, however, she declined his proposal & when the cargo arrived with all his gifts & ring returned, he finally snapped out of his romantic mood.

    That was the end of this all too brief romantic story line & our senator went back to playing chess with his mom.

    ReplyDelete
  12. My maiden attempt - totally inspired by the doctor

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. ๐Ÿ‘

      We had a test player, a one day player. And the set is complete with the T20 player.

      Delete
  13. Gowri that was a fantastic attempt.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Joining the chorus very late. Good show.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Thanx to all of you. That was very encouraging. Be prepared for more such onslaughts!!! ๐Ÿ˜Š

    ReplyDelete

deepakgita@gmail.com