Thursday 12 August 2010

No 9919, Thursday 12 Aug 10, Neyartha

Back from Munnar after an exhilarating holiday with old friends from college.
ACROSS
1   - Damage drum on the lawn with beach plants (6,5) - {MAR}{RAM} {GRASS}
9   - Carbon in box replaced by phosphorus? That is foolish talk! (5) - (c+p)PRATE
10 - Recognises goodwill in conversation on the bridge (9) - (~knows){NOSE}{PIECE}(~peace)
11 - Against the removal of the 101 outdated… (5) - ANciENT
12 - … snack recipes detailed imperfectly in an industrial research centre (7,4) - SCIENCE PARKs*
13 - Flip light in front of the quarter and slip away (6) - {ELAP<-}{SE}
14 - Power to exile Democrat in an American state to a Brazilian city (7) - FLORI(d+p)PA
18 - Feel better about the commanding officer with the priest in retreat (7) - {RE}{CO}{VER<-}
20 - View facing the box office pavilion (6) - {GAZE}{BO}
24 - The French smuggling example is critical (in retrospective) for lawmaking (11) - {L{EG}{IS}{LATIV<-}E}
26 - Egyptian deity's internal turmoil about prescribed times for doing business (5) - HORUS to H{OUR*}S
27 - Somehow ruin peace of the gourmet (9) - EPICUREAN*
28 - Garden nuisance contributing to malaise (5) - ENNUI [T]
29 - Thrower sent out in the wind (11) - NORTHWESTER*
DOWN
1   - Cater to the curate (8) - MINISTER [DD]
2   - Banish external plan that suggested looking back (9) - {RUS{TICAT<-}E}
3   - Wild spaniel found in the ornamental mountain plants (7) - ALPINES*
4   - Fatheads with counterfeit degrees kick the doctor out (5) - GEESEdr*
5   - Cooperative can be improved, if heartless (8) - AMENdABLE 
6   - Page taking out new canvas shoe for the orator (7) - S(n+p)PEAKER
7   - Auditor's footwear on the church plate (5) - PATEN Anno pending (Addendum - See comments for annotation)
8   - Serious actors may covet such roles (5) - MEATY [CD]


15 - The chairman is Pondicherry's leading citizen (9) - {P}{RESIDENT}
16 - Feudal lord's badge protects Oriental on the northbound French street (8) - {S{E}IGN}{EUR<-}
17 - Grove Ron maintained for the superintendent (8) - GOVERNOR*
19 - Stains not initially present on the family's waterproof cloth (7) - {sOILS}{KIN}
21  - Beer bottled in Saudi Arabia and Russia, generally (2,1,4) - {A{S A}{ RU}LE}
22 - Headmaster? (5) - CHIEF [E]
23 - Tendering such money may put one behind bars (5) - FUNNY [CD]


25 - Transmit holograph partially to the metal worker (5) - SMITH [T]

45 comments:

  1. Sorry for the 4 min delay. I forgot to click on the 'Publish' button!!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi all

    Got MARRAM GRASS, SCIENCE PARK (an extra 's'?), RECOVER, GAZEBO, LEGISLATIVE, EPICUREAN, ENNUI (it means boredom or monotony, doesn't it?), NORTHWESTER, MINISTER, ALPINES, GEESE, MEATY, PRESIDENT, SEIGNEUR, GOVERNOR, OILSKIN, AS A RULE, SMITH were OK.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi
    FLORI(-d+P)A was new. As was MAR-RAM GRASS. I was a silly goose not to figure out the GEESE in the first pass, hence you people should probably RUS(TICAT<-)E me, however I RE-CO-VER<-ed the lapse with an OILSKIN. GOVERNOR*, S(+P-n)EAKER, CHIEF, MINISTER, L(EG)(IS)(LATIV<-)E and P-RESIDENT follow a theme, to which HOURS could also be possibly added especially since it comes immediately after LEGISLATIVE forming LEGISLATIVE HOURS as also AS A RULE. Having the same fare regularly makes way for EPICUREAN ENNUI (again two consecutive words). Don’t think it is FUNNY, but I had to adjust my spectacle NOSEPIECE, while time ELAPSEd (probably unusually slower in Munnar ! ).

    ReplyDelete
  4. Col,

    It so happened that I clicked exactly at 8:30 AM IST and refreshed a few times, and I was wondering whether there was a problem :-)

    ReplyDelete
  5. 21 - Beer bottled in Saudi Arabia and Russia, generally (2,1,4) - {A{S A}{ RU}LE}

    For the former case, one could get publicly stoned or executed!

    ReplyDelete
  6. 7d PA of PATEN is probably Public Accountant as in CPA...

    ReplyDelete
  7. Richard,
    No extra S here since recipes are detailed

    ReplyDelete
  8. Auditor's footwear on the church plate (5) - PATEN Anno pending
    {~patent}, perhaps? An incorrect homophone, if so - in PATENT, the final 't' is not silent.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Patten refers to a wooden shoe... Homophone of Paten

    ReplyDelete
  10. 7d I think has a homophone which I have not been able to hear!!

    ReplyDelete
  11. That's right, a person hearing (auditor) of Patten would hear paten, the plate

    ReplyDelete
  12. Richard 839: They could also get 'stoned' drinking too much of it

    ReplyDelete
  13. @shyam: Oh yes. PATTEN fits perfectly. My previous comment withdrawn :)

    ReplyDelete
  14. "Secure a job, almost (5)"

    The above is a clue from today's Guardian cryptic crossword.

    AN CHOR[e]

    No harm in divulging the answer as I need to comment on it.

    I am a little uncomfortable in having to get AN from A. What do other think about this?

    I am raising this question here because if I remember right NJ has used similar device in the past.

    For me "one" might yield A or AN but 'a' can be expected to yield only 'a' and 'an', only 'an'.

    I cannot explain the rationale for this expectation.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Why, I think I don't like it because of a stretch involved.

    one = A or AN (straight)

    Similarly, no stretch is involved in a = A or an = AN.

    But in the case of a = an, I think it's a = one = AN.

    Agree? What is your opinion on this needless jump?

    ReplyDelete
  16. CV You have a point and I have seen a few other NJisms in Guardian; though I cannot recollect them offhand.

    But if you treat 'a' like any other word like 'job' then it may be okay. A can mean an or one. Job can mean op, task, chore etc. Viewed separately it would seem okay. It is a setter's style and not absolutely wrong

    ReplyDelete
  17. Chaturvasi, I think I agree with you. It'd have been all right had CHORE been replaced by a word beginning with a vowel like say AFFAIR or ERRAND to make it AN ACTIVITY or AN ERRAND. AN CHORE doesn't have that continuity and hence doesn't sound right to me.

    Though NJ often uses "one" to clue AN or A, I've not seen her use "a" to clue AN (perhaps I might not have solved them)Personally, I'm not okay with "one" yielding AN either unless continuity (as cited above) is maintained.

    ReplyDelete
  18. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Thanks, Suresh and VJ.

    For me 'one' means 'a' or 'an'.

    But 'a' is only 'a' and 'an' only 'an'.

    Having to get 'an' from 'a' is a setter's style - a style that I don't like, wherever it is.

    PS: If NJ has indeed used it, I cannot quote the clue as I don't have the dB of her clues. Anyone know?

    ReplyDelete
  20. Just referred wikipedia's page on crossword abbreviations. Following is what I found

    "One - i (I is the roman numeral for 1) or rarely a, an (not normally used in British crosswords)"

    Have hardly solved any British crosswords outside Hindu Sunday crossword. Could you confirm on this?

    ReplyDelete
  21. NJism seems to be becoming the 'xerox' of the crossword world!

    ReplyDelete
  22. VJ

    You quote: "One - i (I is the roman numeral for 1) or rarely a, an (not normally used in British crosswords)"

    I think what this means is that one usually yields I.

    ICON can be clued with 'one' and 'study'.

    ACORN can't be clued with 'one' and 'grain' but can be clued with 'a' and 'grain'.

    BTW, I take what is written in parantheses in the quote above to apply only to an. In other words, 'one' cannot be expected to yield 'an'. This seems to reinforce the point I was trying to make.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Friends

    Terminal of a poem (6)

    Would you accept the wordplay in the above clue written offhand for illustraive purpose.

    ReplyDelete
  24. ANODAL?

    If it's NJ it can be any of the following:
    averse
    stanza
    odious
    epopee
    rondel (see how there's END in the letters?)
    passus (end us?)
    ballad (because you said 'friends' and there's 'all' in it)
    ending (because poems have endings, you know)
    TNagar (bus station)
    lethal (disease can be terminal?)

    ReplyDelete
  25. Next few passionate responses from VJ?

    ReplyDelete
  26. Gita, OMFG!!! T Nagar??? Atrocious!!! For the next S&B, don't come without a helmet.

    ReplyDelete
  27. @ CV No It is not right. Not so much because of a becoming an, which I am willing to accept, but because there is no such word as odal

    ReplyDelete
  28. If the answer was 5 letters it would be ANODE, which is acceptable for me. I do not like the surface reading much, in any case

    ReplyDelete
  29. Oh no! There was a mistake in the clue.

    I am cringing. Abject apologies.

    The enu must have been 5.

    The clue was supposed to lead to AN ODE.

    Terminal of a poem.

    Terminal being def, of - conenctor, a - AN, poem -ODE.

    The idea was to ask whether VJ and others would accept 'a' leading to AN because 'poem' yields ODE and AN ODE has what VJ calls "continuity" ( a beautiful term).

    ReplyDelete
  30. Suresh
    You're right.
    The surface reading is not that great.
    But it was written offhand for illustrative purposes only.
    However, 'terminal' does mean 'end' or 'ending' (not just final stop as in bus terminal) and we can think of the ending of a poem.

    ReplyDelete
  31. Of course, CV, the point you were making was whether a can be used as a clue for an. I feel it can. But then maybe it is because I do not like to be bound by convention. One may like or dislike a clue for various reasons. But technically I think it is okay, since I view 'a' the same as any other word.

    ReplyDelete
  32. @Gita: Your comments crack me up!

    This must be a first, but here I agree with VJ. "A poem" can be treated as one unit, giving AN ODE - perfectly acceptable to me on the same lines as a phrase in the clue leading to another in the answer.

    I don't like A = AN when the following word does not start with a vowel, as in the quoted Guardian clue. But if it produces an exceptionally good surface I won't call it too great a crime.

    ReplyDelete
  33. @Shuchi. That was my comment. Still waiting to read VJ's views on this one

    ReplyDelete
  34. Thanks. Suresh, Shuchi and others

    My view on the topic has become clearer!

    Shuchi put it well: " 'A poem' can be treated as one unit, giving AN ODE - perfectly acceptable to me on the same lines as a phrase in the clue leading to another in the answer."

    Even though I wrote that illustrative clue, I was still opposed to 'a' yielding AN.

    Now the resistance may be crumbling!

    ReplyDelete
  35. @Suresh: I guess we all agree more or less. I was referring to VJ's "It'd have been all right had CHORE been replaced by a word beginning with a vowel like say AFFAIR or ERRAND to make it AN ACTIVITY or AN ERRAND. AN CHORE doesn't have that continuity and hence doesn't sound right to me."

    Where I differ with you is in the full green signal for A = AN. The words aren't direct synonyms, only via the meaning of "one". So, in a word-to-word substitution like in the ANCHOR example, I don't like it much.

    ReplyDelete
  36. Sure Shuchi, I personally like ANODE better than ANCHOR. I am only saying that it is acceptable

    ReplyDelete
  37. "The words aren't direct synonyms, only via the meaning of "one".

    This is exactly what I have been meaning from the very beginning.

    'a' is not equal to 'an'

    'a' is 'a' but it becomes 'an' when the word following it starts with a vowel.

    ReplyDelete
  38. CV

    Going back to your post that started this interesting discussion:

    "Secure a job, almost (5)"
    The above is a clue from today's Guardian cryptic crossword.
    AN CHOR[e]


    I wonder whether there is an error in the clue as given. The expected solution is given as five-lettered and the answer proposed is of six letters.

    ReplyDelete
  39. A means AN, only usage may vary. But the that is the same with job and chore also in a way.

    ReplyDelete
  40. Venkatesh
    The enu is 6.
    It is just that I am having a bad day.
    One can't copy-paste a clue from the inter-active version of a crossword. I had mistyped the number.

    ReplyDelete
  41. 5+6=6+5

    What we lose on the carousel we gain on the swings.

    So all is well with the world as Bertie Wooster would say after quoting:
    "
    The snail is on the wing
    The lark is on the thorn

    or rather the other way round"

    ReplyDelete
  42. Chaturvasi, nice illustration. A POEM yielding AN ODE is fine by me and this is exactly what I was trying to convey. Shuchi has explained it pretty well in her comment.

    ReplyDelete
  43. BTW, nice to see people agreeing with me (for a change). Oh no, not really. I kinda like being a contrarian. That's exactly why I started defending NJ. Well whether I was convinced or not, it's a different thing altogether. I know, I'm weird.

    ReplyDelete
  44. Most of us are from outer space anyway...

    ReplyDelete

deepakgita@gmail.com