Sunday, 2 December 2012

Special, Sunday 02 Dec 12, Phantom

Enjoy our new setter Phantoms offering in todays Sunday special. The grid is irregular though.

INSTRUCTIONS

1.  3 answers per commenter in the comments section.
2.  Annotations to be provided. 
3.  Critique welcome.



ACROSS
1   Rum pirate provided with for starters (8)
6   Arrange for camera movement covering lake (4)
10 Walks heavily due to gradient in back street (6)
11 Crook doing time in prison to exercise limbs (7)
13 Rivals appeal considered during contest at end of series (9)
14 Gruelling to pick out fish in making porridge (5)
15 Blowing lid off reality exposes girl (4)
16 Stupidity of alumnus to employ model earlier with cape (10)
19 Struck and given the boot, preparing to retire? (3,3,4)
21 Requests time off from assignments (4)
24 ... says, and one does what's told, or he's out, in children's game (5)
25 Initiator of formal charge throws a fit, if plan goes awry (9)
26 Plague eradicated? It still carries malarial symptoms (4)
27 Remodel public transport system, internally for bridge players first (10)
28 Precise in performing complex actions (5)
29 The Spanish on one foot returned round a street, misdirected (3,5)

DOWN
2   Barrier protecting soldier and his Doberman (7)
3   Concerning girl who is at fault (6)
4   Lab equipment to determine presence of Uranium and Boron in position, being upset (4,5)
5   Goes hungry when the English are not invited to banquets (5)
7   Allow workers at vacant cafe consume leafy fare (7)
8   Extremely sceptical ideologues, believing in nothingness, convey ‘This is nil’ (9)
9   Dialect of Bollywood baddie (6)
12 Press forward including half of us with energy and attitude (6,6)
17 French prisoner revolts losing heart for handcuff set free (9)
18 Friend according to some backstabbed us in the sixties (5)
20 Hollow drum captivating out of step rumba and stringed instrument (7)
22 Saint's anger about right to lead religion, fuelled by inciter (7)
23 Chaotic situations at start of show, supporter turns up on you and me (6)
25 Pearl loses hearing to raised anger and lands in jeopardy (5)



For those who want to solve the CW on another page follow this link PHANTOM

54 comments:

  1. 1A: APERITIF (PIRATE+IF(provided)) anagram
    2D: PARAPET (PARA - soldier, inside PET)
    3D: REMISS (RE=concerning, MISS=girl, def at fault)

    ReplyDelete
  2. 25 PERIL ( Pearl - ear + ire<= )

    ReplyDelete
  3. 5d : F(-e)asts
    11A: Stretch ( Crook doing time in prison // to exercise limbs (DD))

    ReplyDelete
  4. 15 Blowing lid off reality exposes girl (4) tRUTH
    21 Requests time off from assignments (4) tASKS
    mmm... similar
    24 ... says, and one does what's told, or he's out, in children's game (5) SIMON

    ReplyDelete
  5. With Phantom around, others dont have a ghost of a chance ... to walk, Mr Walker?

    ReplyDelete
  6. Replies
    1. Something wrong with the definition here. It should lead to NIHILISMS, but the fodder gives it as NIHILISTS.

      Delete
    2. I think it is fine.

      "Extremely sceptical ideologues, believing in nothingness," (indicates that it is about people not the ideology)

      convey ( Anag Ind)
      ‘This is nil’ (Fodder)

      Delete
    3. Can be NIHILISMS if we take as DD or MD
      Extremely sceptical ideologues// believing in nothingness // this is nil

      Delete
    4. How is extremely sceptical ideologues nihilism ? Also Should it not have been "belief in nothingness" to indicate nihilism.

      Delete
    5. My intention was to define people and this is conveyed by idealogues as explained by Ramesh

      Delete
  7. 10A Walks heavily due to gradient in back street (6)
    TRAMPS RAMP(gradient)+ ST <= ( back street )

    ReplyDelete
  8. 27A [TRA[NS][FOR]MS] Def is given in singular.
    10A T[RAMP]S
    17D [UN(-ten)+CHAIN)ED<] Heart of Detenu in reverse replaced by chain for handcuff

    ReplyDelete
  9. 14A Gruelling to pick out fish in making porridge (5)
    GRUEL Gruel (ling -pick out fish )

    ReplyDelete
  10. Phantom is out on a mission so he will respond to your comments only after he returns tomorrow

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. So who has kidnapped Diana this time ? Not the dreaded Tarakimo again, I hope :)

      Delete
    2. Ask ole man Moz

      Delete
  11. 22 D Saint's anger about right to lead religion, fuelled by inciter (7)
    STIRRER ST(Saint) +IRE (anger)+R (right)+R{(lead religion)

    ReplyDelete
  12. for 22D duplicated
    7D: LETTUCE, Allow=LET, vacant c(af)e must be CE. Workers is TU? (trade union, I don't know). Pl help.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes. Workers can be TU ( from Trade union as you have rightly pointed out )

      Delete
  13. 2d: sorry, para+pet (read protecting in a bit of a hurry)

    ReplyDelete
  14. 9D - {B}{ROGUE}
    16A - {OB}{T}{USE}{NESS}
    19A - {HIT} {THE} {SACK}

    ReplyDelete
  15. 12 Press forward including half of us with energy and attitude (6,6) FO(U)RTH, E + STATE
    18 Friend // according to some backstabbed us in the sixties (5) CHINA (DD)
    20 Hollow drum captivating out of step rumba and stringed instrument (7) T(-abl)A + MBURA*

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Bhavan, a technical question on 18: Seems that this is coming from cockney rhyming slang (first def). While 'China' could equate 'Mate', does it work backwards also with a completely different word that means 'Mate'

      Delete
    2. http://www.thefreedictionary.com/china: gives the following meanings for this: noun (Brit. & S. African informal) friend, pal, mate (informal), buddy (informal), companion, best friend, intimate...

      Delete
    3. That's cool. Actually my question was more generic (just used your clue as an example) as to acceptable logic in framing the clue. For example, if 'China' did not have a direct meaning as 'friend', would it be acceptable?

      Delete
    4. And by way of clarification let me add that the question arose because I associated it with the rhyming slang (which is the origin), not being aware of a straightforward definition

      Delete
  16. 28 A Exact -hidden clue
    Ganesan

    ReplyDelete
  17. 26A-Ague (Plague-pl)
    malarial symptoms-def-Ague

    ReplyDelete
  18. 13A-Opposites

    Rivals- def
    Appeal considered- Oppos (Oppose-E)
    contest- Tie*
    End of series-S

    ReplyDelete
  19. 29A- It should be (3,6) and not (3,5)-Led Astray
    Spanish-EL (but I dont find a reversal indicator)Is it round?
    One foot- Yard?
    A street-Ast
    Misdirected- Def.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Is round a reversal indicator for both 'The Spanish' & yard?

    ReplyDelete
  21. Someone pl. clarify how 'one foot'becomes yard?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Returned is the reversal indicator, though how one foot is a yard beats me as well

      Delete
  22. Col,

    Back to the skull cave as mission's accomplished earlier than I thought and to receive B & B. Diana is safe and sound.

    Thanks, Col for hosting this puzzle of mine and to the participating members who spared their time to work out the answers.

    My apologies for an irregular grid and having missed the plural in 27 AC.

    ReplyDelete
  23. 13 Rivals appeal considered during contest at end of series (9)

    Def: Rivals,

    Appeal: IT

    Contest: Oppose. Verb form.

    IT in OPPOSE and end of series : S OPPOS(IT)E + S

    As regards 29 The Spanish on one foot returned round a street, misdirected

    I again apologise to all as I had intended something else and totally landed up with a big Goof up! I do not have any plausible explanation for this clue. I had 'carriage' in mind but did not correct the clue while sending to the Col.

    I sincerely hope apart from this, the other clues are acceptable to all and hope to come up with an improved puzzle with no loose ends the next time Col decides to host me.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Does Phantom like Melody (chocolate)?

      Delete
    2. How did you know, Kishore?

      Delete
    3. Melody khao, khud jaan jao!

      Delete
    4. Kaheen pe nigahen, kaheen pe nishaana...

      Delete
    5. Crypticism has reached a level where I am not able to figure out anything.

      To add to confusion. Nishaana is way off the mark.

      Delete
  24. I had not realised until I read the comments that china could mean friend. I was thinking of 'hindu chini Bhai bhai.'

    ReplyDelete
  25. With so many bloggers becoming sloggers, maybe there will come a time when there are only sloggers and one blogger (myself).

    ReplyDelete

deepakgita@gmail.com