Thursday, 12 November 2020

No 13091, Thursday 12 Nov 2020, Dr. X

Solution to 20D has been deliberately left unsolved and is to be answered only by a non-regular / novice commenter, with proper annotation. Those who have answered earlier in the week, please give others a chance. 

ACROSS
1   Winning side takes time off (8) WRESTING {W}{RESTING} (Correction - {W{REST}ING} - See comments)
5   Son, worried and frightened (6) SCARED {S}{CARED}
10 Attack with knights, pinning rook back (5) KNOCK {K{CON<=}K}
11 Religious person about to criticise analyst (9) THERAPIST {THE{RAP}IST}
12 Narrow escape with new system preventing shock (4,5) NEAR THING {N}{EARTHING}
13 Groom in stress after removing top (5) TRAIN sTRAIN
14 Learn about tackling essentially complicated type of equation (6) LINEAR {L{c...lIc...d}NEAR*}
15 Accumulate runs quickly to secure victory on time (7) HARVEST {HAR{V}ES}{T}
18 Spirit shown by woman in trouble (7) BANSHEE {BAN{SHE}E}
20 Summon a coalition to control European country (6) MONACO [T]
22 I want flexible brace (5) TWAIN
24 Heedless drunk scratching bottom in open (9) OBLIVIOUS {OB{LIt}VIOUS}
25 Doctor’s glorious, operating on ureters essentiallyd (9) UROLOGIST {GLORIOUS*}{ureTers} Semi&lit
26 Engineers checking old-fashioned circuit (5) ROUTE {R{OUT}E}
27 Charge a Republican involved in dispute (6) TARIFF {T{A}{R}IFF}
28 About the French kiss — it’s sloppy (8) CARELESS {CARE{LE}SS}
    
DOWN
1   Comedian entertaining family is stimulating (6) WAKING {WA{KIN}G}
2   Calling Veronica to slyly abandon Reggie at entrance (9) EVOCATION {VErONICA+TO}*
3   What Test opening batsmen aim to do to overshadow? (4,3,5,3) TAKE THE SHINE OFF [C&DD]
4   Crazier nationalist starting to instigate in state (7) NUTTIER {N}{UTT{In...e}ER}
6   Fellow gets snappy about including extremely detailed exact reference (7,3,5) CHAPTER AND VERSE {CHAP}{TER{AND}{VERy}SE}
7   Side dish at fair, served without topping of fruits (5) RAITA {AT+fAIR}*
8   Blow up in meeting over revolting remark (8) DETONATE {D{NOTE<=}ATE}
9   Section of the lung’s damaged — avoid snuff essentially (6) LENGTH {THE+LuNG}*
16 Guard keeps goon mostly in cage (9) ENCLOSURE {ENCLOS{cUR}E} (Addendum - {EN(CLOd)SURE} - See comments)
17 Old boy on cocaine in swank bar (8) OBSTRUCT {OB}{STRU{C}T}
19 Sensational to mention about eating beef in retrospect (6) EXOTIC {CIT{OX}E}<=
20 Civilian army bombed central barricade in revolutionary mission (7) M?L?T?A (Addendum - MILITIA {MI{LIT}{b..rIc..e}A<=} - See comments) 
21 Drug addicts consuming heroin are escorts (6) USHERS {US{H}ERS}
23 Love affair in morning time when husband’s away (5) AMOUR {AM}{hOUR}

Reference List
Son = S, Knight = K, New = N, Victory = V, Time = T, Engineers = RE, Republican = R, The in French = LE, Nationalist = N, Old boy = OB, Cocaine = C, Heroin = H, Husband = H


39 comments:

  1. Very interesting puzzle as always. My favourites are 22a, 25a, 3d and 6d. Thanks for making my morning interesting.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I took 16d as
    EN{CLO(-d)}SURE
    Ensure=guard
    Clod=goon

    ReplyDelete
  3. 20d MILITIA ...MI(LIT)b...(I)..e A
    Mission ....AIM in reverse bombedis LIT
    I is centre of barricade

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, that is correct Orthopaul👍. (Bombed= Lit as in drunk)

      Delete
  4. What better thing to do on a rainy morning than solving the mysteries of Dr.X?!
    Thank you Doc. for an engrossing start for the day/

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Enjoy your rainy day, Paddy!

      Delete
    2. Yes,Doc. Rain here is still in the enjoying stage,not the worrying type.

      Delete
    3. Wow ..nice light rain here also today. I immediately made a black tea and went to the balcony to enjoy the rain

      Delete
  5. Enjoyed 10A the best. Made it look like a chess puzzle.
    A most plausible chess situation,but when you break it down there are no chess elements in it.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I always like simple and elegant ones, like today's 9 & 23 Dn. Thanks Doctor.

    ReplyDelete
  7. 24A- Had a good laugh at Doc.'s way of getting LI from LIT- Drunk scratching the bottom'!!

    ReplyDelete
  8. 19 Sensational to mention about eating beef in retrospect (6) EXOTIC {CIT{OX}E}<=
    I had a doubt how ox can get beef. I looked up.
    (Newbies, this is what I expect of you. If you have doubt, first look up the word{s} in dictionaries before asking 'how is ox = beef?')
    I have just learnt
    ox - animal
    beef -cattle raised specially for their beef
    Thus my problem was resolved.
    Did anyone else have similar experience?

    ReplyDelete
  9. Re 5a
    Can 'cared' (past tense of "care" be used to mean 'had worries, concerns, etc.' I thouht of example sentences.
    He cared for his mother very much after father passed away. Means he gave her protection and help.
    I decided that 'cared' can be used in the sense of worried in a negative sentence.
    He never cared for the big ugly spots on his face..
    So cared = worried seems ok.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This makes a lot of sense. I could not comprehend cared for worried before.
      15a: Runs quickly means a HARE (singular). What is the clue for getting S.

      Delete
    2. Hi! Hare (verb) means to run quickly. Hence Hares = Runs quickly

      Delete
    3. Hi CV Sir, one of the meaning of Care as verb is 'to be anxious' or 'to be concerned'. As in 'He cared/worried about the damage to the environment'

      Delete
    4. Worried also means scared. Son misled me.

      Delete
    5. In the most obvious sense care for could be worry about. But without object , it can be worry though a slight stretch

      Delete
    6. In the most obvious sense care for could be worry about. But without object , it can be worry though a slight stretch

      Delete
  10. Dr X , thank you.You were considerate to dumbheads today.Thomphil

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This comment has been removed by the author.

      Delete
    2. Mr Thomphil, I don't think anyone who attempts and cracks cryptic clues could ever be a dumbhead!

      Delete
  11. Doc, is K for Knight ok? In chess , it is either N or Kt.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. 01 K, N 02 AK, Kt in Chambers

      Delete
    2. Yes SSv it is. See Chambers Dictionary (BRB). The knight= K is not from chess notation but from Knight of the British empire.

      Delete
    3. Exactly what I said earlier- the situation described (pinning rook back) makes us think only about chess,but there is nothing about chess in the cryptic part. That is beauty of the clue. The knights are not from chess.

      Delete
    4. If K for Knight is from KBE (Knight of the British Empire), then why do some solvers raise objection if I (or any other setter) uses a letter from a similar multi-letter abbr, for any single letter among them?

      Delete
    5. Hi CV Sir. Chambers Dictionary unfortunately does not include the etymology for abbreviations (at least not in every case). Under the heading K, it clearly mentions the following--

      King (as in cards and chess) but does not specify anything when Knight is listed.

      What I meant by my statement is that the Knight referred to is not the chess Knight but the British empire Knight. I do not know if it is derived from KBE or it Knight= K stands by itself. Still, this much is sure, several Dictionaries have Knight= K.

      Delete
  12. Nice. Just wondering...
    After the "near thing"
    And the way you clue
    Dr Are you engineer too?
    Word play arithmetic anazing

    ReplyDelete

deepakgita@gmail.com